Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Offseason Position Discussion : 3B

Out of all the Nats positions, third base had the least consistency. Brady House manned the position for a good part of the year, but also spend some time in AAA. While he was down Curtis Mead played the hot corner for a quarter of the season and then was gone in a trade.  Vivas was the back-up and also played about a quarter of the season there. Clearly Mead is not the answer but is Brady House?  For what it's worth, his return from AAA put up better numbers than before leaving eschewing power for a more rounded and successful approach (.227 / .282 / .399 vs .268 / .343 / .395). 

Presumed Plan : 

House gets another shot at the position full-time while they deal with figuring out the middle infield.  He may get crowded out if all the Nats MI prospects ALL look super good this year, but seeing as that's unlikely he's here until he fails with Vivas as the back-up again. 

 The wild card here is Cayden Wallace.  After some middling time in the minors Cayden seemed to put it all together last season and had good half years at both AA and AAA. Was this just a one-year blip?  If not then Wallace will push House with his strong defense and power bat. in House's favor is that Wallace is almost two years OLDER than House and his "swing at everything" profile is going to face a big test in both approach changes in AAA and if he gets to the majors - the top notch quality of arms here. 

Reasoning behind Presumed Plan : 

You can't solve everything all at once.  House had all the earmarks of a multi-year MLB player as a prospect and with only about 1 full season of games under his belt and still young (he'll turn 24 mid next season) no conclusions can be drawn yet.  His hitting has improved with every up and down he's taken and if he can hold onto what he was doing at the end of last year and pair it with better defense (which dipped in 2026) then he's a major leaguer. Nothing special but not everyone on your team is going to be an All-Star. Also he could keep improving into an All-Star, the kid seems to keep learning. 

Vivas is the exact "solid fielder, decent enough bat" that should be on the bench for your team unless it's competing to be the best of the best.  

Wallace is the type of prospect that can excite you at first glance but upon further look questions arise.  Is this just a minor-league veteran now playing against kids? Can that swing profile hold up against guys that can make proven bats look foolish?  If he can hit like he did in AAA again for the first couple of months though, you have to find out. But it will be a couple of months. 

My Take :  

I see no issues here. The plan with House is solid. In general, I've liked him as a player and think he's on the precipice of that "mutli-year starter" level that we pegged him for. Let's see if he can get there. Vivas is a solid back-up.  Wallace is a decent contingency plan although I'm not as high on him because of his presumably not great eye.  That may play in the sticks but DC ain't Rochester.  Honestly his AAA profile isn't too far off of House's.  The difference is House was doing that in a season he turned 22 not 25. Wallace is close to being "we have House at home" 

3 comments:

  1. Note that House has the exact same 2026 xwOBA as CJ Abrams--.333. I think this portends an above average season with the bat for House next year.

    ReplyDelete
  2. House is the guy unless you want to make a run at Sato. Given his age, I think you give him more time to develop. If he can improve the plate discipline, he'll be a legit All-Star. His batted ball profile is great...he just doesn't make enough contact. Near the bottom of the league in chase rate, whiff rate, K rate, BB rate, and sweet spot rate. So if he can get choosier with his pitches, his above average hard hit rate, xBA, xwOBA, xSLG, etc all play into a top 10 3B at minimum

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. also, Harper, not sure if you can do anything about it but the bot accounts in the comments are killing me

      Delete