Is the Nats lineup good?

The Nats have scored 5.4 runs per game in the first quarter of the season.  That just isn't good - it's second best in baseball good. But to Nats fans this feels very weird. Sure they could be better than average if the pieces came through but second best in baseball? If you told me that last year I would have had at least some Dylan Crews fighting for ROY expectations. 

What do the stats say?  

BASE

Average - .244  t10th

OBP - .325 t9th  

SLG -  .411 t6th

HR - 50 t9th

SB -  42 4th

BB - 155 14th  

OPS+ 111 - t5th

These all say the Nats are a little bit overperforming but nothing crazy because they don't really have any holes in their offensive game. Like maybe they shouldn't be 2nd best but Top 5 is reasonable.  

Except for SB this is a huge change from last season.  What happened?  Well - Luis Garcia is still Luis Garcia but he's putting up better numbers at 1B than baseball's least favorite canine Nathaniel Lowe. Brady House is rounding into at least an average bat after struggling mightily last year. Lyle is better than Dylan Crews. Jose Tena et all are at least matching Josh Bell. But mainly Wood and Abrams are hitting like MVP candidates when last year they were solid and above average respectively.  Outside of Nunez replacing Garcia at 2B everything is better. 

FANCY

 Their launch angle as a team is improved (it could hardly be worse) but other than that there isn't much outside of some minor improvements that would suggest getting to average.  

 Some of this is likely the Nats just getting better because they have young players and that's what young players do.  Hit it a little harder, a little better, swing at fewer bad pitchers. 

RELATIVENESS

But here's probably the kicker.  The usual way a baseball season works is April is the worst month for hitting then teams heat up until the end of the season when a combination of not trying, resting for playoffs, and kids brought up bring down the stats again. There are vagaries that can affect this but this is the general way of a season. 

In May 2026 the Nats have been hot in the first third of the season jumping up from .718 to .799 in OPS.  The league as a whole?  Down from .715 to .688. I can't say this is unprecedented but we haven't seen it in recent years. So while the Nats have gone on a hot streak baseball itself has gone dead cold and a team that was about average in April now finds itself in front with a good chunk of the reason being other teams flubbing their expectations. 

WHAT DOES THIS ALL MEAN

For the Nats and their offense - it's still early (remember our Memorial Day pledge for when stats count) but it looks like they are better and the terrible offense of 2025 is at least average thanks to some bounce backs and growth. Expect them to land where you'd expect an average offense to be over the past few seasons. 

For MLB I don't know. Like I said - we haven't seen this.  In April the average OPS was .715.  In May that would rank 9th.  That itself undersells what's going on as the gap between 9th and 10th is over 20 pts.  That's big. Teams are just not hitting.  If that's a real thing and there's a new normal, well then the Nats would seemingly benefit from just getting a better from awful.  It's not about being some universal best, it's all about relative best. 

My guess is though the season will find the Nats drifting down to around the 10th+ range, both as Abrams and Wood settle, as their runs scored match their stats, and as other teams shake off this weird early funk. But still Top 10 ish is better than expected and lends some hope to what 60 days ago looked pretty hopeless.