Nationals Baseball: NL ROY question

Monday, November 15, 2010

NL ROY question

If you voted for Posey, then I assume it was based on a "he was better when he was out there" line of thinking. But if that's the case, why not vote for Strasburg then? It seems to me if you valued production over the course of the full season Heyward was the pick and if you valued sheer awesomeness when in there Strasburg was the selection.

My guess is that there was a lot of hedging "well one third of a season is too little but two-thirds is good enough" which is fine, but I'd like to hear a Posey supporter say as much instead of saying "he was the best when he could play!" because we all know who would win an argument based on that reasoning alone.

No comments: