Nationals Baseball: Offseason Position Discussion : 1B

Friday, October 30, 2026

Offseason Position Discussion : 1B

2026 was the year of "Let's Try with Nasim Nunez and Brady House". Why does that matter?  Well with CJ Abrams set at SS that meant House was at 3B and Nunez needed to be at 2B. And THAT meant Luis Garcia needed to be at 1B.  Potentially the freedom to not worry about the defense of 2B let Garcia think about hitting more and he had his best year at the plate, blasting past his career high in homers even before he was traded. 

But yes he was traded leaving a hole at first filled with whoever was around and that was mainly Andres Chaparro, though youngsters Yohandy Morales and Abimelec Ortiz both got time at first as well. Ortiz, a fast riser, struggled.  Morales, a long time "hmm this guy looks better than we thought" prospect, looked good. Chaparro leading the way looked honestly great.  

Presumed Plan : 

Andres Chaparro starts at first. If he struggles Morales picks up the spot.  Ortiz back to AAA to maybe earn a spot depending on who falters at 1B and DH. 

Reasoning behind Presumed Plan : 

Chaparro is on the clock and if the Nats don't see him in their future then they probably see him as potential trade bait and that needs to be showcased if it's going to get the best return. Anyway you look at that you see a guy playing.  That doesn't mean he has to play 1st but 3B will likely be House again, who put up slightly above average numbers after a dismal start, and you tend to cycle at DH more than first.   

My Take :  

It's tempting to hand the spot to Yohandy who has proven himself at every minor league level and is younger, thus more likely to be the future, but denying the half-season Chaparro when he has also consistently been better than AAA would be a mistake.  One mistake teams make is thinking "we have too much good" when usually that is only true for half-seasons where the right number of people are healthy and a couple guys are having good runs.  So focus on the proven good here. 

Also, probably more importantly, Chappy's good was over 228 PA compared to 47 for Morales.  Morales also was putting up HR/FB rate where every third fly ball was a homer.  If he keeps that up he's the greatest home run hitter in history, so I'm going to say chances are he won't. 

As for Ortiz - prove it. 

13 comments:

Anonymous said...

Chappy can DH. Morales should get as many at bats as possible this coming season as long as the power remains. He is a better defensive 1b than Chappy. Chappies bat is essential for a Nats team if we are competing for the playoffs. But the glove tries hard and still is weak.

Anonymous said...

Well, Harper you seem to have missed something big. Seattle just hired C. J. Gillman as their new hitting coach. So who is C.J. Gilman, you ask? This past year he served as the National's Director of Hitting. He is the guy who put together the hitting philosophy that the Nationals used this year. Everyone has praised the improvement in hitting by the Nats players and assumed it would continue. Now the architect of the plan has left. Let's see what happens in the future.

Harper said...

Another "this year doesn't matter at all" approach? Not up for it. Really never up for it but really not after a "wait why didn't we try this year" season

Harper said...

Let's see who replaces him before we get worried.

Anonymous said...

I think the jury is still out on Chappy, but I agree, he's earned a shot to see if this is real. If his batting is real, I think he's at best a 3rd 1st baseman (not a super utility guy) - and alt DH with Wood if he has really come into his own in a power bat kinda way.

Anon said...

Unless you have a star, I like the idea of platooning 1B and DH. James Wood is a star, and I'd pencil him every day as DH (given his OF shortcomings) and try to see if he can play a decent/competent 1B. You could run a more complicated platoon arrangement and have Wood play DH against lefties (putting Crews and Young in the OF) and play in the OF against righties.

The problem with the platoon approach is that the candidate bats in the system are RH heavy (Chapparro and Morales) and the LH bat (Ortiz) performed the worst of the three last year in MLB. If Chapparro hit LH, I'd feel a lot more confident about our in-house options. Unless the FO has a lot of confidence in Ortiz, I think there's a decent rationale to sign (or trade for) a solid LH bat to play 1B and DH.

kubla said...

These guys are fine, but 1B seems like the easiest place to pick up a power bat. I'd like to see an ambitious move or two. Obviously the offseason focus should be on pitching, but the offense once Mead and García were gone was a little shaky. Having enough players with the potential to step up can cover an injury or slump from Wood and/or Abrams.

Also what is the plan with trading for Nate Furman? Why do they need a AAAA middle IF help? And trading pitching for it? You may cover this in the 2B post, but I'm completely baffled by it.

Anonymous said...

Re: Furman. Because they think they can coach his up to be a better utility infielder than the sad collection of players who have occupied that spot over the last few years? https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2026/11/nationals-acquire-nate-furman-from-giants.html

Mike Condray said...

One problem with Morales at first base: can he hit MLB velo? I remember a knock on him even in his good 2026 AAA campaign was that he had real problems catching up to pitches above 95 mph. I only saw him in a few games (SSS of a SSS alert!). But what I did see was consistent with that scouting report, with Morales doing major "That Ball Had A Family!" level damage to a couple of off-speed pitches but not doing much to 95+.

If he can't hit 95+ velo that will get seriously exposed at the MLB level. On the plus side, it's a pretty clear issue for Morales to work on in the off-season (and they can talk to him about it until 1 Dec).

OnHockey.org said...

I lean toward giving Chaparro the first crack, given his 228 plate appearances last year versus Morales' 47, but the platoon idea makes sense if neither proves he can handle the full job. Like many fans who follow team-building across sports — I also read OnHockey for that kind of roster debate — I think 1B is the easiest spot to add a power bat if the in-house options stall. Either way, letting Morales prove whether he can hit big-league velocity in spring training seems like the right first test.

Anonymous said...

Some very good lefty infielders are hitting the FA market this year. That's where I'd start.

NHLBite said...

I lean toward giving Chaparro the first crack, given his 228 plate appearances last year versus Morales's 47 — that's a much fairer sample to judge, even if Morales has the higher upside. The point about not overreacting to a hot half-season also rings true, especially with Ortiz needing to prove it back at AAA first. As a fellow sports fan who also follows hockey in the offseason, I usually check Live Hockey NHL between baseball debates like this one.

DezoPenguin said...

Have to give Chapparo full-time ABs until he proves 2026 was a flash in the pan. 141 wRC+ over 228 PAs. 142 against LHP, 141 against RHP, so he's not screaming "platoon me." If he's legitimately "figured it out" then he's the solution to either 1B or DH, not a placeholder. I feel like he mostly plays 1B because the Nats like to cycle people through DH, though I'd prefer Chapparo at DH and Morales at 1B since Morales is the better fielder.